Gatcombe Farm Suffers The Tragedy We All Knew Was Coming
Gatcombe faces the loss of 13 cattle following restrictions on enhanced bovine TB testing.
Robert Reid and his family have today received the heartbreaking news that 13 of their prized cattle have tested positive as reactors to the bovine TB skin test and will now have to be slaughtered.
This is a devastating blow to a pioneering farm in South Devon which, over recent years, has led the way in developing innovative strategies to tackle bovine tuberculosis (bTB), successfully restoring its herd to officially TB-free status without killing a single wild animal.
Tragically, this setback was not unexpected. It was only a matter of time.
The Gatcombe Protocol, developed and implemented under the guidance of experienced veterinary surgeon Dick Sibley, enabled the farm to regain its officially TB-free status in just three years.
At the heart of this approach is a straightforward principle: identify infection within the herd, understand how it spreads and interrupt the routes of transmission.
An essential part of this strategy is enhanced testing, using diagnostic methods designed to detect infection that may be missed by the conventional skin test.
Yet, in a cruel irony, once the farm regained its officially TB-free status, government regulations prevented the continued use of the enhanced testing programme.
The very strategy that had helped the farm achieve its success was effectively stopped in its tracks.
Without access to these additional diagnostic tools, there was a risk that undetected infection could once again become established within the herd.
Dick Sibley believes that renewed testing may reveal that infection entered the herd through young replacement cattle, remained undetected by routine skin testing and subsequently spread to adult animals.
The concern is that infection in its early or latent stages may not produce a detectable response to the conventional skin test, allowing infected animals to remain unidentified.
Robert was unable to continue using the enhanced testing methods that had formed such a crucial part of the Gatcombe Protocol because doing so would have breached the regulations applying to his herd.
The question must be asked: why should farmers be prevented from using additional diagnostic tools that could help identify infection earlier and protect their cattle?
Supporters of the existing policy of routine skin testing and badger culling may seek to use this tragedy as evidence that the absence of badger culling contributed to the breakdown.
But the experience at Gatcombe tells a very different story.
Throughout the project, evidence gathered on the farm has supported the importance of cattle-to-cattle transmission, herd management, biosecurity and identifying infected animals that conventional testing may miss.
The project also identified evidence of infection in local badgers, with contaminated slurry considered a possible route of exposure.
Crucially, the cattle herd was able to regain officially TB-free status despite the presence of infected badgers and without culling them.
At one stage, a shortage of badger vaccine meant that vaccination could not take place. Nevertheless, the cattle herd continued to progress towards officially TB-free status.
This was one of the most significant observations from the project, challenging the assumption that killing badgers is necessary to achieve disease control in cattle.
Now that the herd has lost its officially TB-free status, enhanced testing can resume, allowing Dick Sibley to investigate what has happened, identify potential sources of infection and determine how transmission may have occurred.
Anne Brummer and Sir Brian May have been involved in the Gatcombe project throughout, working alongside Robert Reid and Dick Sibley.
The arrangement has always been clear: Dick leads the veterinary work with the cattle, while Anne and Brian focus on the badgers and their protection.
Together, the project has sought to demonstrate that a science-led approach to bovine TB control can prioritise cattle health without resorting to the destruction of wildlife.
The latest setback makes the need for regulatory reform even more urgent.
Farmers should have access to the most effective diagnostic tools available, supported by appropriate veterinary oversight, rather than being restricted to testing regimes that may fail to identify infected animals.
Dick Sibley said: . We are not regarding it as a reason to change our strategy. We fully believe that in the fullness of time the Gatcombe Protocol will be vindicated, and eventually adopted throughout Britain, as the ONLY way of eradicating bovine TB.
But we desperately need the Government to change those regulations which apply to enhanced testing.”
The loss of these cattle is heartbreaking for Robert Reid and his family. It is also a stark reminder of the consequences that can follow when farmers and their veterinary surgeons are unable to continue the disease-control strategies they believe are working.
The Gatcombe project has demonstrated that alternative approaches deserve serious scientific consideration.
Rather than continuing to rely on badger culling, the Government must urgently review the regulations governing enhanced cattle testing and support the development of effective, evidence-led strategies for controlling bovine TB.
We must protect cattle, support farmers and stop the unnecessary killing of wildlife. These objectives should never be treated as mutually exclusive.
Sir Brian May and Anne Brummer
Save Me Trust